On St. John has a mission that we would've happily accepted: find the best rum punch in St. John. This rum punch from Aqua Bistro in Coral Bay certainly looks like a contender to us. It's made with dark and light rum, orange and pineapple juice and grenadine, and finished with a rum floater, lime and cherry on top.

The Aqua Bistro rum punch: $6 all day long.